Transcription vs. Fretboard Logic: How to Learn the Jazz Language
What was the question?
Malik asked specifically about the "Fundamental Course" and the study of Wes Montgomery ’s "4 on 6." His dilemma was whether he should focus on transcribing the language to internalize the sound, or if he should focus on "seeing the fretboard more clearly" to understand the logic. He felt he knew what the lines were but couldn't execute them cleanly yet. [08:14]
The core idea (in plain English)
Learning jazz is exactly like learning a spoken language. You can study grammar books (fretboard logic), but you truly learn to "speak" by immersing yourself in the conversation (transcription).
Think of it like watching an American drama to learn English. If you watch the whole season, you start to pick up the accent, the timing, and how phrases are actually used in context—even if you don't know the exact grammar terms yet. To get familiar with Wes Montgomery's rhythmic language, you generally need to transcribe the "whole thing" rather than just isolated licks. [11:42]
Fretboard breakdown (what to play)
The challenge with Wes Montgomery’s vocabulary isn't just the notes; it is the starting point of the phrase.
Upbeat Formatting: Wes is an "upbeat person." His phrases rarely start squarely on the downbeat. [13:10]
The Assignment: Before you analyze the theory, you must be able to play the transcription in time.
Tempo Rule: "In time" does not mean full speed. It means steady tempo. You can slow it down, but the pulse must be consistent. [09:35]
Common mistake to avoid
Do not try to extract "licks" too early. People often say, "just take a lick here and make it yours." In this method, that comes way later. First, you must absorb the entire flow—the "blueprint key map"—before you start cutting it up. If you skip this, you miss the rhythmic syntax that makes the notes work. [10:13]
A 10-minute practice assignment
Take a 4-bar phrase from a Wes Montgomery solo you find difficult. Instead of speeding it up, slow it down to 60 BPM (or lower). Record yourself playing it. Listen back: Are you starting exactly on the upbeat where Wes does? If you can play it perfectly in time at a slow tempo, you are ready to move to the next part. [13:10]
How to join the next Office Hour (Free)
To submit your questions and watch these lessons live:
Register for Essential: Building Blocks (Free Account)🔗
Submit your questions via the Office Hour RSVP Form🔗
Catch up on past sessions in the Replay / Office Hour Archive🔗