A Single Sentence from a Master: "It Still Sounds Like 6 to Me"
Youthful Ambition and the Master's Mirror In the journey of becoming a musician, there are periods of tangible technical growth, but there are also moments when a single experience, a single sentence, can completely shift your perspective on music itself. I had one such moment. During my Master's studies in Michigan, I was fascinated by complex odd meters. At the time, I think I believed that complexity was evidence of a more advanced, more modern musicality. At the peak of this youthful ambition, I undertook the bold challenge of rearranging Wes Montgomery's masterpiece, "Full House," from its original 6/8 time signature into 5/4. In my mind, it was a rather brilliant endeavor.
The Story: A Piercing Remark from Peter Bernstein One day, the masterful guitarist Peter Bernstein visited our school as a guest artist. After his workshops and performances, he graciously joined the students for a jam session. Seeing this as an unmissable opportunity, I confidently played my ambitious 5/4 arrangement of "Full House." Subconsciously, I might have been expecting praise—perhaps a comment like "innovative" or "interesting." After the performance, I walked up to him to say hello. His response was nothing like what I'd anticipated. With a calm, matter-of-fact expression, he said to me: "Hey man, this is still 6 to me." In that instant, it felt like being struck by lightning. I thought I had deconstructed and reassembled the original piece with complex rhythms and harmony, but in the ears of a master, it just sounded like the original melody's accents were being awkwardly forced into a 5/4 grid. I hadn't escaped the melody's inherent rhythmic gravity. That single sentence taught me a crucial lesson: complexity is not synonymous with progress. The essence of music doesn't lie in its technical packaging, but in how deeply one understands and respects the inherent life force of its melody and rhythm. From that day forward, I learned the importance of first perfectly understanding and internalizing a piece of music in its original form before trying to change or add to it. Perhaps my struggle to play "Full House" in its original 6/8 during the live stream, which was captured in the transcript, is connected to that experience. The memory of the 5/4 arrangement was interfering with the natural flow of the original.
📸 [IMAGE 2 INSERT HERE] Conclusion:
A Constant Return to the Essential Peter Bernstein's remark became a pivotal milestone in my musical journey. It instilled in me the habit of asking fundamental questions before relying on flashy techniques or complicated theories. Questions like, "Can I truly sing this melody with sincerity?" and "Do I feel the heartbeat of this rhythm?" Sometimes, the greatest lessons don't come from long lectures, but from a single, short sentence that forces us to stop, reflect, and look inward. Do you have an unforgettable phrase that has shaped your own musical journey? For more stories about music, growth, and inspiration, visit VoiceLidJazzGuitar.com.