Jazz Guitar Upper Structures: Why Analyze Donna Lee as Targets and Stacked Chords Instead of Bebop Scales?

There are two correct ways to analyze Charlie Parker's Donna Lee, and only one of them helps you on the guitar. The first labels every note against a scale: A♭ major bebop scale here, ♭13 over F7 there, 9 over B♭7. The second reads the line as chord-tone targets, chromatic approach notes, and upper structures: the stacked chord sitting on top of each harmony, like Dm7♭5 over B♭7. Junewon Choi walked through both analyses side by side on a VoiceLid Jazz Guitar live stream to show why the second one is what his online jazz guitar lessons teach. The first answers "what is this note called?" The second answers "where does this line live on the fretboard?"

What Does the Scale Analysis Say?

It names everything. Donna Lee is in A♭ major. Look at the opening phrase and you'll find a note with a natural sign that doesn't belong to A♭ major. In a scale analysis, that's the chromatic passing tone of the A♭ major bebop scale, the extra note between the 6th and the 5th. Move to the F7 and the line becomes ♭7, then a ♭13 tension, then the 5th, then the 4th passing into the 3rd, then 5, ♭7, root. When the harmony reaches B♭7, the same pitches get new numbers: what was a root is now a 5th, and the line runs 3, 5, ♭7, 9.

Junewon is clear: none of that is wrong. It's accurate. It's also already complicated, and that's only a few bars.

What Does the Target Analysis Say?

It finds the notes that matter and treats the rest as connectors. Over F7, the important notes are E♭, C and A, the ♭7, 5th and 3rd. Everything between them is chromatic, a half step leading into the next target. Target, target, target, chromatic. That's the line.

Next comes a small turn around F: the line steps up and comes straight back down. Some people call this an enclosure, but Junewon describes it more simply as an ornament from F to F. The F is the point; the note above it is decoration.

Then the harmony moves toward B♭7, and the line outlines Dm7♭5. That's the first upper structure in the phrase.

Why Is Dm7♭5 the Upper Structure of B♭7?

Because stacking thirds and removing the root gets you there:

  • B♭7 is B♭, D, F, A♭.

  • Add the 9th (C): B♭, D, F, A♭, C.

  • Remove the root (B♭): D, F, A♭, C, which is Dm7♭5.

That's the same direction jazz harmony itself grew: triads, then seventh chords one third higher, then bebop adding one more third on top. Junewon's point is that this much you do need to know. You need to know that the next third up exists and what chord appears when the root drops out. What you don't need is a label for every note. For a deeper look at bebop as stacked thirds, see Decoding Bebop: Upper Structure Triads and the Architecture of Modern Jazz.

Why Does the Second Analysis Work Better on Guitar?

Because on guitar, the same pitch lives in many places. On piano or saxophone, an E♭ has one key or one fingering. A scale analysis maps straight onto the instrument, and for those players it's brilliant. On guitar, you can play that E♭ in several spots, and each choice changes the phrase. Two guitarists playing the same line in unison will often be in different positions.

The target analysis solves this:

  1. Start from the key center. A♭maj7 is A♭ major, so start from the Wes Line position: the major-triad shape on the 2nd, 3rd and 4th strings that guitarists use as home base in a key.

  2. Anchor the resolution. The phrase lands on F, so find the F where it can resolve, then ask where C and E♭ must sit to arrive there.

  3. Let half steps become slides. From that E♭, slide down a half step and you're at D, the root of the Dm7♭5 shape.

  4. Expect the upper structure before it comes. When B♭7 is next, you already know Dm7♭5 is waiting on top of it.

Junewon's phrase for this: everything makes sense. You see why the position is the position, and the upper-structure chord appears naturally from where your hand already is. For the full map of how these stacked chords connect to shell voicings and voice leading, the Bridge Series builds it step by step. For another look at the bones of this same melody, read Analyzing the 'Bones' of Bebop Melodies (Donna Lee).

Does This Change How the Line Sounds?

Yes. Once the position comes from the targets, the articulation follows. You pick the first note, pull off, slide into the next target, and the phrase swings without any forced accents. Played from the scale analysis, the same line tends to come out as alternate picking on every note, which flattens it.

Junewon learned this the hard way. At Berklee he sat in improvisation classes built around running a bebop scale through a tune's changes, alongside students on every instrument. The method wasn't wrong, he says, but it didn't fit the guitar. It wasn't until he absorbed his teacher's approach that he understood why.

What's the Takeaway?

Use the scale names if they help you talk about the music. But when you learn a bebop line on the guitar, look for the targets, the chromatic notes leading into them, and the upper structure each chord is hiding. That analysis tells you where to play. If you want to build that kind of fretboard map from the ground up, Fundamental 1: Wes Diagonal System lays out the Functional Diagonal Approach step by step.

About the Author

Junewon Choi is a Berklee-trained jazz guitarist and the founder of VoiceLid Jazz Guitar, an online education platform teaching jazz harmony and improvisation through the Functional Diagonal Approach (FDA) — a chord-first method built on voice-leading rather than scale boxes.

Next
Next

Get Swing Articulation on Guitar Like a Sax Player?Jazz Guitar Improvisation Tips: How Do You